Please Vote! Is a hot dog a sandwich?

Bringing back the age old question of if you consider a Hot Dog a sandwich.

Why do you think it is or isn't?

Can you back it up?


- Respectfully
Moose Moose Moose

 

The sandwich is one of the most influential dishes in western cuisine due to its standardized fabrication procedure and versatility. However, despite its ubiquity, the question of" what is a sandwich?" remains up for debate, terrorizing workplace lunchtimes across the continent. We present a self-consistent sandwich definition comprising only six axioms with the power to categorize every meal. Notably, our model asserts that certain controversial dishes such as burritos and hot dogs should be regarded as sandwiches.
-Orad Reshef, Dept. Of Physics, University of Ottawa

http://reshef.ca/2019 Reshef - Is a hot dog a sandwich.pdf

 

S4 all over again

 

he debate over whether a hot dog qualifies as a sandwich is a topic that has ignited passionate discussions among culinary enthusiasts, language aficionados, and even legal experts. To delve into this subject, it's crucial to examine the components, structure, and defining characteristics of a sandwich.

At its core, a sandwich consists of two pieces of bread or a bread-like substance, with a filling nestled in between. Applying this definition, a hot dog undeniably fulfills the fundamental criteria. The bun, which is typically used to envelop a hot dog, can undoubtedly be regarded as the bread component. While it may have a different shape and texture than traditional sliced bread, it serves the same purpose of enclosing the filling. The fact that the bun is a continuous piece of bread, rather than two separate slices, does not invalidate its role as the bread component, as many sandwiches, such as subs or hoagies, are made with similar bread structures.

Moreover, the hot dog filling itself plays a crucial role in defining the sandwich. The hot dog is typically a cylindrical meat product made from ground beef, pork, or a combination of both. It is placed within the bun, creating a clear separation between the bread and the filling. This separation is a defining feature of a sandwich, as the filling is contained within the bread structure, ensuring that each bite encompasses both elements.

Furthermore, when discussing the classification of a hot dog, it's essential to consider the wider context of culinary categorization. Sandwiches encompass a diverse array of creations, ranging from the classic ham and cheese sandwich to extravagant combinations like the club sandwich. The essence of a sandwich lies in its versatility and adaptability, with endless possibilities for customization. In this context, the hot dog undoubtedly fits into the broader concept of a sandwich, as it encompasses the core principles of a bread-based enclosure filled with a variety of ingredients.

It is worth noting that the discussion extends beyond mere semantics. Legal authorities and industry organizations have grappled with this topic as well. For instance, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) recognizes hot dogs as sandwiches in their labeling guidelines, further solidifying the argument that hot dogs belong in the sandwich category. Legal cases have even been presented to courts to address the question of whether hot dogs are sandwiches, highlighting the significance of this debate beyond culinary curiosity.

In conclusion, a hot dog is unequivocally a sandwich. It meets the necessary criteria, consisting of a bread component (the bun) and a filling (the hot dog), enclosed within the bread structure. The versatility of sandwiches and their inclusion of diverse ingredients supports the classification of a hot dog as a sandwich. Ultimately, whether you indulge in a hot dog at a baseball game, a backyard barbecue, or a street food cart, you can confidently assert that you are enjoying a delicious sandwich experience.

 

A hot dog is a sandwich parading as a taco.

 

When I slide my hot dog into the bun it is sandwiched in-between the soft folds of the bun. Thus it is a sandwich.

 

Damn gonzo you didn’t have to get all sexy about it.

 

Ain’t a hotdog just a hotdog

 

The question of whether a hot dog is considered a sandwich is a subject of debate and largely depends on how one defines a sandwich.

Traditionally, a sandwich consists of two slices of bread with a filling in between. By this definition, a hot dog, which typically consists of a sausage or frankfurter enclosed in a single long roll, may not fit the exact criteria of a sandwich.

However, some argue that a hot dog can be classified as a sandwich because it consists of bread (the roll) with a filling (the sausage). They believe that the defining characteristic of a sandwich is the presence of bread and filling, rather than the specific structure of two separate slices of bread.

Ultimately, whether a hot dog is considered a sandwich or not is subjective and can vary depending on personal opinion and the specific definition one chooses to apply

 

Objectively speaking, based on the generally accepted definition of a sandwich as a food item consisting of two or more slices of bread with filling in between, a hot dog does not qualify as a traditional sandwich.

A hot dog typically uses a single piece of bread, known as a roll or bun, that is split on one side to hold the sausage. In contrast, a sandwich usually involves two distinct slices of bread. This fundamental difference in bread structure sets a hot dog apart from what is commonly understood as a sandwich.

However, it is important to note that the classification of a hot dog as a sandwich can vary depending on different interpretations and definitions. Different people or culinary traditions may have their own perspectives on this matter, leading to subjective opinions and debates.

 

A hot-dog is one slice of bread, a sandwich is two. So no. If a hot-dog is a sandwich, it would be called a sandwich.

 

Title: Is a Hotdog a Sandwich? A Classification Conundrum

Abstract:
This essay explores the classification of a hotdog within the realm of culinary taxonomy, specifically addressing the question of whether a hotdog can be considered a sandwich. By examining various definitions and characteristics of sandwiches and comparing them to the structure and components of a hotdog, this essay aims to shed light on the ongoing debate and highlight the subjective nature of such categorizations.

Introduction:
Food classification has long been a topic of interest, often triggering passionate discussions and debates. Among the myriad culinary creations, the hotdog has emerged as a contentious subject, challenging the conventional notions of sandwich classification. This essay delves into the question of whether a hotdog can truly be considered a sandwich, employing the framework of sandwich definitions and evaluating the structural similarities and differences.

Defining a Sandwich:
To approach the classification of a hotdog, it is essential to establish a working definition of a sandwich. According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a sandwich is "two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between." This definition emphasizes the presence of bread and a filling, suggesting that a sandwich consists of two distinct layers enclosing a central component.

Examining the Hotdog:
A traditional hotdog comprises a sausage or frankfurter, typically placed in a slit hotdog bun. Analyzing this structure, we can observe similarities with the definition of a sandwich. The bun serves as the outer layers, functioning similarly to bread, and the sausage acts as the filling. In this sense, a hotdog aligns with the basic criteria for a sandwich, as it consists of bread enclosing a filling.

Differentiating Factors:
While a hotdog exhibits some characteristics of a sandwich, it also possesses distinguishing elements that set it apart. Firstly, the shape of the hotdog bun, usually a long, partially split roll, deviates from the conventional square or rectangular shape of sandwich bread. This distinct form may lead some to argue that a hotdog is more akin to a taco, which traditionally employs a folded tortilla.

Moreover, the structural integrity of a hotdog is another factor to consider. In a classic sandwich, the filling is typically placed between two separate slices of bread, creating distinct layers. However, in a hotdog, the bun is not completely split, and the sausage resides within the confines of the bun, making it a cohesive unit. This distinction challenges the idea of a hotdog as a sandwich, as the filling is not entirely enclosed by bread.

Subjectivity in Classification:
The classification of a hotdog as a sandwich or otherwise ultimately highlights the subjective nature of food categorization. Culinary classifications are often influenced by cultural and regional variations, personal perspectives, and historical context. Different individuals may have varying opinions on the matter, shaped by their experiences and culinary traditions.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the classification of a hotdog as a sandwich remains a subject of debate. While a hotdog shares some characteristics with a sandwich, such as the presence of bread enclosing a filling, it also possesses distinguishing features, such as its distinct bun shape and the cohesiveness of the filling. Ultimately, the classification of a hotdog as a sandwich or a separate entity highlights the subjective nature of food categorizations and underscores the importance of acknowledging diverse perspectives in culinary discussions.